Pick Your Paradise: Maui vs. Big Island

Hawaii, a tropical haven in the middle of the Pacific Ocean, boasts a collection of mesmerizing islands each offering their own unique charm. Among these, Maui and The Big Island stand out as two prominent destinations. You might be wondering about the pros and cons of each. It's so hard to pick, but if you have to choose just one to visit, here's what you might want to know before planning your trip to paradise. Read on to learn more about these extraordinary islands, and how HomeExchange can host you in Hawaii!

Discover How HomeExchange Works

Weather: Tropical Weather Tendencies Between Maui & The Big Island

When it comes to weather, both Maui and The Big Island offer distinct microclimates. All in all, if you're wondering about Maui or The Big Island pros and cons for weather, it's hard to say there are any downsides to either. Even a tropical rainy day on both islands is spectacular and gives way to gorgeous rainbows!

Maui: Perfect Beach Weather All Year Round

Maui benefits from its location shielded by the towering West Maui Mountains that create a microclimate keeping western and southern regions of the island relatively dry and sunny throughout the year. Places like Kaanapali and Kihei enjoy a moderate and consistent climate, making them ideal for beachgoers and sun-seekers. The temperatures in these areas typically range from the high 70s to mid-80s Fahrenheit (around 25-30 degrees Celsius). However, it's worth noting that the eastern side of Maui, including Hana, receives more rainfall due to the influence of trade winds and the island's topography. This lush region offers verdant landscapes, waterfalls, and a tranquil escape from the sun-soaked beaches.

Big Island: An Astonishing Array of Climates

The Big Island, or Hawaii Island, has an astonishing array of climates due to its size and diverse topography. On the west side, popular destinations like Kailua-Kona and Kohala Coast experience a dry and sunny climate, with temperatures ranging from the low 80s to mid-90s Fahrenheit (around 27-35 degrees Celsius). This region, often referred to as the "Kona side," benefits from the rain-shadow effect caused by the towering Mauna Loa and Mauna Kea volcanoes. As a result, it experiences less rainfall and more consistent sunshine, making it perfect for outdoor activities and beach exploration. On the eastern side of The Big Island, including Hilo and the Hamakua Coast, the climate shifts to a more tropical and wet environment. The influence of the northeast trade winds brings more rainfall, nurturing lush rainforests, botanical gardens, and spectacular waterfalls.

Scenery: So Much to See on Maui & The Big Island

Both Maui and The Big Island have stunning landscapes that showcase the natural beauty of Hawaii in their own unique ways. The scenery of Maui vs Big Island can best be simplified as Maui being a lush garden isle, and the Big Island being a testament to incredible volcanic landscapes.

Maui: A Lush Garden Paradise

Maui, often referred to as the "Valley Isle," offers a picturesque blend of lush valleys, pristine beaches, and dramatic coastline. The Road to Hana, a scenic drive along Maui's eastern coast, takes travelers through a tropical paradise of cascading waterfalls, bamboo forests, and panoramic ocean views. The journey includes stops at iconic attractions such as the Twin Falls and the Wailua Overlook, which provide breathtaking vistas of the coastline and the Pacific Ocean. Another remarkable natural wonder on Maui is the Haleakala Crater, located within Haleakala National Park. This dormant volcano rises over 10,000 feet (3,000 meters) above sea level and offers awe-inspiring views from its summit. Visitors can witness breathtaking sunrises or explore the otherworldly landscapes within the crater, characterized by vibrant colors, cinder cones, and unique flora.

Big Island: Dramatic Volcanic Landscapes

The Big Island, renowned as the largest island in the Hawaiian archipelago, captivates visitors with its diverse and dramatic scenery shaped by volcanic activity. Hawaii Volcanoes National Park, a UNESCO World Heritage Site, showcases the island's volcanic wonders. Visitors can witness the power of nature at the active Kilauea volcano, where lava flows and vents create a otherworldly landscape. The park also features the fascinating Thurston Lava Tube, a natural tunnel formed by flowing lava, and scenic hiking trails through lush rainforests and desolate lava fields. The Big Island also features diverse ecosystems, including tropical rainforests, rolling pasturelands, and breathtaking waterfalls. Akaka Falls State Park, north of Hilo, showcases the 442-foot (135-meter) Akaka Falls, surrounded by lush vegetation and a picturesque bamboo forest. The Waipio Valley, often referred to as the "Valley of the Kings," offers a glimpse into Hawaii's rich history and features steep cliffs, taro fields, and a black sand beach.

Beaches: Enjoy Different Shorelines on Maui & The Big Island

Neither Maui or The Big Island disappoint when it comes to beaches. The Big Island has rocky, volcanic shores, and by comparison, Maui has an abundance of beautiful beaches with soft, white sand. When considering beaches in Maui or Big Island pros and cons, Maui's beaches are slightly more commercial and developed, while The Big Island's are more wild and remote.

Maui: Postcard Perfect White Sand Beaches

Maui has a collection of stunning beaches with golden sands and crystal-clear waters. One of the most popular is Kaanapali Beach on Maui's western coast. This three-mile (4.8 km) stretch offers excellent swimming, snorkeling, and a bustling atmosphere with resorts, restaurants, and shopping. Wailea Beach, situated in the resort area of Wailea, is another picturesque spot on Maui's southwest coast. Here the waters are calm, sands are soft, and views of the neighboring islands are breathtaking. For those seeking a more secluded beach experience, Makena Beach State Park, also known as "Big Beach" or "Oneloa Beach," provides a wide expanse of pristine shoreline. With its turquoise waters, golden sand, and rugged lava rock formations, it is a favorite spot for sunbathing, picnicking, and bodyboarding.

Big Island: Stunning Black & Green Shores

The Big Island is home to more volcanic beaches, with stunning green and black sand coasts. Punalu'u Beach, located on the southeastern coast, showcases jet-black sands contrasting with turquoise waters. It's a haven for endangered sea turtles, which often bask on the beach. Papakolea Beach, situated near the southernmost point of the United States, has unique green sands created by olivine crystals eroded from a nearby cinder cone. These distinctive beaches offer a surreal and unforgettable coastal experience. Hapuna Beach, situated on the Kohala Coast, is often ranked among the best beaches in the world. With its white sands, crystal-clear waters, and excellent swimming conditions, it offers a perfect setting for sunbathing, snorkeling, and bodyboarding.

Accessibility: Getting To & Around Maui & The Big Island

When it comes to the accessibility of Maui vs Big Island for families and others looking to keep travel time to a minimum, Maui holds an advantage due to its smaller size. The island features a well-developed infrastructure, making it easier to navigate and explore. Maui's main airport, Kahului Airport, offers direct flights from major cities, ensuring convenient travel arrangements. On the other hand, The Big Island's vastness can require more travel time. However, it offers two airports: Kona International Airport on the west side and Hilo International Airport on the east side, providing options for arrival and departure. If you want to stick with more direct flights, head to Maui. But don't be discouraged to head onward to The Big Island. Inter island flights in Hawaii are quick and easy!

Prices: What Varies Between Maui & The Big Island

Considering prices, it's important to note that both Maui and The Big Island offer a range of accommodations and activities to suit various budgets. Maui, being a more popular tourist destination, tends to have slightly higher prices for accommodations, dining, and attractions. The Big Island, with its larger size and more diverse offerings, presents a wider range of options to cater to different budgets. From luxury resorts to budget-friendly accommodations and affordable local eateries, visitors can find choices that align with their vacation budget. Whichever island you choose, when it comes to Maui vs Big Island for families and others on a budget, HomeExchange can offer a great way to save on accommodations so price isn't a determining factor when it comes to choosing the island that best suits your style.

Maui or Big Island: Pros and Cons

So how can we sum up Maui vs Big Island? One thing is for sure: both islands serve up a slice of paradise Hawaiian style and won't let you down.

• If you're looking for more convenience, commerce, and postcard perfect sandy beaches then pick the ultra lush garden island of Maui.
• If you're craving more adventure, unique landscapes, and getting off the beaten path, pick the positively volcanic Big Island for your Hawaiian holiday.
• If you're looking for affordability, you might want to pick The Big Island as its larger size allows for more varied budgets.

If you have the time, why not experience both? As we said, island hopping is easy with inter island flights and ferries. Another amazing experience in Hawaii is just over the rainbow, so get out and explore all of the islands if you can!

HomeExchange in Hawaii

HomeExchange is proud to have hosts and homes in Hawaii for your next home exchange! If you're looking to get away to paradise, then Hawaii is the place. From its natural gifts like the amazing weather, scenery, and beaches to the incredible culture and history, there is so much to see, do, and enjoy here. Settle into the perfect home away from home to discover Hawaii like a local. Sign up to start setting up a HomeExchange and get in the beautiful aloha spirit...paradise awaits!

See homes in Hawaii